An Overview Of The Catalan Political Parties Competing In The November 2012 Election

With elections to the Catalan Parliament called for November 25th and the campaign about to get under way here in Catalonia, it struck me that a brief overview of the political was in order as if you’re not familiar with Catalan politics, all the names can be a little confusing.

There are 135 seats at stake so an absolute majority is 68. I’ve given the number of seats/percentage of vote each party has in the current legislation in brackets.

The four parties in favour of continuing the independence process are:- Convergència i Unió (62-38.47%), Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (10-7%), Iniciativa per CatalunyaVerds (10-7.39%) and Solidaritat Catalana per a la Independència (4-3.28%). The pro-Independence parties currently hold 86 seats out of 135 corresponding to 56.14% of voters and these numbers look likely to increase following the next election.

I’ll go into more detail about the positions of the respective parties below but the parties who are not in favour of Catalan independence are:- Partido Popular de Cataluña (18-12.33%), Ciutadans (3-4.4%) and Partit dels Socialistes de Catalunya (28-18.32%). The three parties currently hold 49 out 135 seats corresponding to 35.05% of the electorate. Polls suggest that PPC and Ciutadans are likely to remain solid as the opposition parties (21-16.73%) whilst the PSC  will probably lose about a third of its voters.

A gross simplification of the intention to vote culled from various different polls would be 55% in favour of independence, 15% against and 30% undecided.

So let’s look at the parties one by one.

Convergència i Unió (CiU)

Convergència i Unió (CiU)

Convergència i Unió (CiU)

CiU are currently Catalonia’s ruling party and look likely to again this time with an absolute majority of more than 67 seats. Under leader Artur Mas, they have been called to lead the pro-independence block although Mas is careful not use the word ‘independence’ preferring terms such as ‘own state’ and ‘sovereignty’. Despite being a Catalan Nationalist party, CiU has never previously come out in favour of independence and has often pacted with the government in Madrid. The lesser member of the coalition – Unió, led by Josep Duran i Lleida – even now are not fully behind the independence movement.

Partit dels Socialistes de Catalunya (PSC)

Partit dels Socialistes de Catalunya (PSC)

Partit dels Socialistes de Catalunya (PSC)

PSC have traditionally been the second most powerful party in Catalonia, generally controlling Barcelona City Council. They are affiliated to, but theoretically independent of, PSOE and have always consisted of two factions – one more PSC and the other more PSOE. They are the major casualty of the independence process as their current leadership under Pere Navarro looks more towards Madrid whereas their voters would like to see more of the C in PSC. They also have the problem of being without a coherent policy. They propose federalism but then get publically embarrassed by the PSOE barons in Madrid and the rest of Spain. The big question is ‘Where will the disaffected PSC vote go?’

Partido Popular de Cataluña (PPC)

Partido Popular de Cataluña (PPC)

Partido Popular de Cataluña (PPC)

The Madrid government’s franchise in Catalonia has never been popular but as they capture the anti-Catalan vote, they are inevitably the main party opposing independence and the referendum. The PPC is led by Alicia Sánchez Camacho and their campaign is based on how much they love Catalonia. They even speak in Catalan, which is a little strange as most of their voters are monolingual Spaniards. They may pick up a few frightened CiU voters but I’d be surprised if they capture more than 15% of the vote.

 

Iniciativa per CatalunyaVerds (ICV)

Iniciativa per CatalunyaVerds (ICV)

Iniciativa per CatalunyaVerds (ICV)

Formed out of a merger between the old Izquierda Unida Iniciativa per Catalunya and the Green Party, ICV are ecosocialist and Catalanist. They are in favour of independence but leader Joan Herrera is definitely not happy about being in the same boat as CiU and seems to spend as much time criticising Artur Mas as he does Alicia Sánchez Camacho. However, they’ll probably pick up a good number of disaffected PSC voters.

 

Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (ERC)

Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (ERC)

Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (ERC)

ERC (Catalan Republican Left) are traditionally Catalonia’s pro-independence party. They’ve suffered from poor leadership in recent years but current leader Oriol Junqueras comes across as much more intelligent and capable than his predecessors. An ex University Professor, he’s succeeding in putting across a left-wing message combined with the idea that being pro-Catalan doesn’t necessarily imply being anti-Spanish, either culturally or linguistically.

 

Solidaritat Catalana per a la Independència (SI)

Solidaritat Catalana per a la Independència (SI)

Solidaritat Catalana per a la Independència (SI)

Originally, the formation included ex-Barça president Joan Laporta, the idea behind SI was to bring the pro-independence parties together.  Led by Alfons López Tena, as a political party in their own right, it’s difficult to see what’s different about their message so they could well disappear. It strikes me that their usefulness is more as a pressure group along Reagrupament lines.

 

 

Ciutadans (Cs)

Ciutadans (Cs)

Ciutadans (Cs)

Cs (Citizens) have got a Catalan name but only speak in Spanish. They are anti-independence and propose a strange mixture of right and left-wing policies, which remind me of the National Socialist parties that came into existence during the depression. However, they are likely to pick up the votes of Spanish-speaking ex-PSC voters so they have to be taken into consideration. Leader Albert Rivera reminds me of the early 20th century anti-Catalan leader Alejandro Lerroux – the Emperor of the Paral.lel!

 

10 comments for “An Overview Of The Catalan Political Parties Competing In The November 2012 Election

  1. November 4, 2012 at 12:01 am

    Many thanks for an objective overview. In a multi-party system the battle grounds are often fuzzy and unholy alliances are formed to cobble together ruling or opposition groupings.

  2. November 4, 2012 at 6:10 pm

    Oh, what a beautiful fairy tale! Certainly an objective overview, as Steve Hall points out. Isn’t live easy to understand? I’ll tell you, listen:

    Catalans = good. Bloody Spaniards = bad.

    Catalans for independence = good Catalans.

    Catalans against independence = bad Catalans. Besides, they are not Catalans, but bloody Spaniards, however they feel.

    Monolingual Spaniards = pure evil = PP voters. Fortunately they will be no more than 15%, so we can forget they even exist. Not a single Catalan speaking will vote PP – you can trust me. Not even Alicia darling.

    Anti-independence = anti-Catalan. ¿Don’t we have a little problem here? If Duran (CiU) is right, and most of the people in Catalonia is anti-independence (quite probable), then it follows that a majority of Catalans will be anti-Catalan. No, not a problem now that I come to think about it. Being anti-independence make them not proper Catalans. Maybe we can get rid of them or something.

    Yes, very objective overview. Perfectly clear portrait of nationalism. A bit too much, if I may be somewhat crude.

    • November 4, 2012 at 7:26 pm

      I’m writing from a pro-independence point of view and trying to be as fair as possible, but I have to admit I feel a deep-seated dislike for the Partido Popular.

      However, I was expecting to be criticised for my opinions on Ciutadans – I don’t know, but sincerely they come across to me as a bunch of complete and utter lunatics!

      • November 4, 2012 at 8:01 pm

        No doubt they would be my option if I lived there. I am interested in your opinion they are lunatics. Could you explain?

        • November 4, 2012 at 8:26 pm

          They’re just totally WEIRD!

          • November 4, 2012 at 8:36 pm

            I know. You have been brainwashed, and C’s is saying about everything you hate. This makes them weird … or maybe it makes you weird. It’s completely dependent on the point of view. You look weird to me (nothing personal, excuse me).

  3. viejecita
    November 5, 2012 at 4:30 pm

    Mr Simon Harris
    Sir:
    You say Ciutadans has a Catalan name, but speak only Spanish. You say too that they remind you of the Nazi party ( you actually say the National Socialist parties that came to existence during the depression. I take it you talk of the Great Depression of 29 and early thirties. So it should mean the Nazis ; I don´t think you are talking about “The New Deal” ).

    But that is not at all so.
    I have often heard Rivera speaking Catalan, when speaking in the Parlament.
    And they are pro- liberties. And don´t look for other people as scapegoats, in order to blame them for everything. So, that makes then not at all similar to the Nazis.
    And they take risks, by speaking clearly. And by denouncing, with names and data, the cases of corruption in the Catalonia Health Administration. ( Those I have read and seen, they must have denounced other corruptions, or they would not be so hated by the politicians in power ).

    Maybe they are a bit weird, if you compare them to other parties, who try to say a thing and its contrary at the same time, in order not to lose votes. But it is a good weird. I find them refreshing, and hope they will get lots and lots of votes.

  4. Jim
    November 7, 2012 at 10:49 am

    Simon, thanks for this overview.
    It’s very useful for someone like me as start point for further reading!

    • November 7, 2012 at 1:01 pm

      Pleasure, Jim, please bear in mind that it’s my own overview so it’s not completely objective.

      I’ll admit I’ve always moved between PSC and Esquerra … I’m a leftie … and am quite uncomfortable giving my support to the overly conservative CiU.

      One of the reasons, I support independence actually is because it’s the only way to have a normal – right, lef, centre – political spectrum.

      Catalanism ought to irrelevant … unfortunately, it isn’t (yet!!!) ;-)

Leave a Reply